Pizza Restaurant
Goodfellas Pizzeria

(9 reviews)

427 East Kirkwood Avenue, Bloomington, IN 47408

About Goodfellas Pizzeria

Get New York-style pizza done right at Goodfellas Pizzeria. Located in Bloomington, IN, this local pizzeria offers customers a fun spot to enjoy delicious food. No matter what you’re in the mood for, their menu offers something for everyone.

From pizza to breadsticks, this restaurant takes pride in their ability to bring great food to their customers. Known for their friendly staff and excellent menu, they stay true to their New York roots by focusing on family and community. Stop by and try one of their tasty lunch specials, or ask about their loyalty program!

Goodfellas Pizzeria is the go-to spot in Bloomington for mouthwatering New York-style pizza. Their thin-crust pizzas are made from fresh dough, hand-tossed, piled high with your favorite toppings, and baked to perfection on a pizza stone. You can even choose from a variety of savory meats, fresh veggies, and delicious cheeses to make your own pizza. If you’re feeling adventurous, give their specialty pizzas a try, or grab some pizza by the slice to take on the go. Don’t forget to pair your pie with breadsticks, salads, or one of their tasty desserts!

In the mood for something different? Try their signature meatball sub, the Al Pacino. This extra-large sub is topped with their homemade meatballs, smothered in their signature marinara sauce and mozzarella, and presented on a toasted Tribeca baguette. Other customer-favorite menu options include their calzones. Stuffed with fresh ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings, their calzones will leave you feeling full and satisfied every time. 

Whether you’re picking up or dining in, you’ll find the best New York-style pizza in town at Goodfellas Pizzeria. Call (812) 822-0010 to place an order or to make a reservation, or check out their website to browse their menu. Be sure to connect with them on Facebook to stay up to date on their specials.



(4 reviews)


(3 reviews)

(2 reviews)

"Today we left to get lunch without a place in mind to eat. As we were walking down the road, my sweet boy asked me if I had ever had "Goodfellas", to which..."... more
- Jessi A. [Yelp, July 24, 2021]